One of the most common and sticky criticisms of Singapore is that it’s sterile.
Part of this can be a kind of orientalizing Western perspective – the assumption being that Asia is supposed to be dangerous, exciting, and that Singapore is just too clean and clinical for the adventuring westerner.
But also, simultaneously, there’s a truth to it that Singaporeans ourselves will acknowledge to be true. And there are reasons for this. Singaporeans didn’t wake up one morning and collectively decide that we wanted to be boring. In fact, Singapore used to be called “Sin Galore” by sailors who docked at our harbour back in the 1950s. Bugis Street was once the place to catch “The Dance of the Flaming Arseholes“.
I think it was only after the PAP government came to power that Singapore began to become sterile, with the intent of maximising economic growth. The idea was to make Singapore a safe haven for foreign investment – and keeping things boring, predictable, stable and sterile was a significant part of that in the decades since independence in 1965.
There’s more to dig into here, I’d like to really dive into it and expand this post into a proper exploration. To be continued. Here are some old reads.
- Sterile Singapore – travelblog.org, 2005
- Singapore sterile and dull? – Tripadvisor, 2011
- Is Singapore too sterile? – Quora, 2013
- Why I’ll never return to Singapore – Danny Dover, 2013. “I would describe my time living in Singapore as sterile. Nothing particularly bad happened, but it wasn’t particularly good either. Daily life was convenient, but it was only the bare minimum of living. I had everything I needed to be comfortable, but I didn’t have anything that inspired me.”
- Singapore – Not as sterile as I expected – Paula McInerney
- Americans: Does Singapore feel sterile? – Singapore Expat Forums, 2014
- The price of life in Singapore, city of rules: ‘It’s a Faustian deal’ – theguardian.com, 2015
- Is Singapore sterile and boring? – Anja, 2018
- Is Singapore really as boring as everyone thinks? – telegraph.co.uk, 2018
- “everyone tells me the city is quite boring and sterile” – /r/singapore, 2020
- tourist finds singapore artificial (mothership, 2023)
✱
- Sandy Sandfort – The Intelligent Island [1993]
- Singapore as Potemkin Metropolis [2007]
- Singapore, the perfect world capital [2011]
- Singapore’s not-so-grim “Disneyland” [2012]
- How Lee Kuan Yew made Singapore the most prosperous, efficient, and quirkily repressive country in Asia [2015]
- Singapore’s funky apartments are like candy for the eyes [2015]
- Yes We Got Soul, Says Singaporean
- Singapore Got No Soul, Says Foreigner
- Danny Dover – Why I’ll Never Return to Singapore – HN
- ARCHIVE – Five Reasons Not To Travel To Singapore – Response 1 – 2 – 3 – 4 – 5 – 6
- Expat mum about Singapore train
- Singapore Is Undemocratic
- Why they hate Singapore [2008] – HN
- Singapore is repressive
- Singaporeans Cannot Do Naughty Things
- Shisha Ban
- Alcohol Ban
- Chewing Gum Ban
- Smoke Weed Overseas
- Singaporeans Cannot Do Naughty Things